Risk Scenario Analysis

Risk scenario analysis requires imagination and most importantly collaborative brainstorming in order to identify all risks, even and especially risks that today seem outlandish. As an example, I would have never considered Amazon stopping non-essential product shipments but this is exactly what was enacted as a response to this pandemic. One of the consequences of this action has been a significant impact on small businesses that utilize Amazon for their warehouse and order filling support. This in-tern impacted the success of a great deal of small businesses that were dependant on the Amazon fulfillment services which impacted the livelihood of many employees along with the success of the small business. This then fed into the overall economic impact from the pandemic. This is a great example of the relationships and overall impact of seemingly unrelated decisions on a wide range of people and businesses.

The above example is the key reason why it is so important to perform robust risk scenario analysis. In the example above the impacted businesses now must evaluate the risk of the fulfillment disruption and how they can react to this disruption to support their business. Business must develop a strategic risk management process that views scenarios for any and all risk to the business. Starting in the beginning of this yea the waves of disruption experienced to date have shown that you cannot eliminate a risk because it will never happen. We have gone through a series of disruptions that previously were simply unimaginable as a real risk and so there were no response strategies developed.

The first step is to identify and fully document the risk scenario. This means that the risk scenario must not only identify the potential risk, it must also identify the potential impact to the market and also the business. The definition of the risk is not complete though until you have identified and documented how to sense the risk so that you can execute your planned response. This means that you should identify and document 'outlandish' risks as well as generally accepted risks. The outlandish risk may never materialize however it is important to call out the scenario so that you can take steps to minimize the potential as well as prepare for the realization of the risk.

This is an important point - one of the objectives of the strategic risk analysis and a key outcome are steps that can be taken that will minimize the potential for the risk. This is a concept that needs to become a focus of every risk mitigation strategy because the best way to react to a risk is to eliminate the cause of the risk. Simply defining the risk and the potential impact to the market in general and your business specifically will help to identify how to sense the risk. This exercise of risk identification and early recognition will provide the framework to define the steps necessary to eliminate the risk from occurring.

Risk scenario analysis and mitigation has always been an important aspect of project planning and management. We must institute this same practice now in the supply chain management and business continuity process. As a result of the rate and impact of disruption hitting the market and businesses we must recognize that risk analysis can no longer be viewed as an inward facing exercise. As a result of the disruptions hitting this year we must finally recognize that business continuity must be and outward facing strategy that recognizes early the factors developing of the disruption and takes steps to mitigate and avert major impact.

Tom Brouillette

Contact: tbrouillette@ncspartners.com

@ncspartners

Strategic Risk Management To Counter VUCA

Hope For The Best And Plan For The Worst should be a consistent and shared mantra for all businesses as a means to focus on strategic risk management. The importance of this has increased to the highest level as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and the activities to both recover and prepare for the next disruption. This requires a significant investment in strategic risk mitigation definition and development and must include partner risk management in the scenario development and risk mitigation strategy. This includes all partners and integrations in the extended supply chain. The weakest link in the supply chain will continuously change depending on the type of disruption and your strategic risk scenarios must be developed to define a response for all scenarios.

One critical activity, or requirement, is implementing a regular risk scenario review process that evaluates the likelihood of scenarios and most importantly, new scenarios. As we have seen from the many disruptions experienced so far this year risk scenarios and potential changes continuously with new risks rising and other risks declining and disappearing. You will never in a million years be able to identify all risks, and the point is that a regular review process provides the means to review so that you can add and remove scenarios as necessary.

The next activity is developing and implementing the appropriate data analytics capabilities that will support the ability to sense the reactions to disruptions and most importantly, the reaction to combinations of disruptions. The risk scenarios must identify the reactions to combinations of disruptions and then you must have a means to measure the responses. This is where data analytics comes into play, along with a healthy helping of imagination. Different disruptions and combinations of disruptions will cause different reactions in the supply chain and these reactions must be identified quickly in order to determine the appropriate response. The risk scenario identification and evaluation is important but it is based on assumptions and personal viewpoints of the team that developed the scenarios. Data analytics brings the facts to the table to help to determine the appropriate response.

The glue that connects these processes and activities is imagination. Risk scenarios require imagination to create, risk response exercises require imagination to develop, data analytics requires imagination to develop the queries and identify the appropriate data and source to identify the reaction to the disruption and then to validate the effectiveness of the response. As you can imagine, this is not a ‘once-and-done’ exercise. This requires continuous review and evaluation in order to grow and evolve with the market and the supply chain. Each disruption and reaction to the disruption creates a new reality stream that changes scenarios and potential for disruption and it is important to continuously evaluate and develop new scenarios.

Data analytics is a very nebulous practice that requires continuous experimentation and evaluation to validate assumptions. The data analytics initially produces the outcome reaction to disruption and combinations. This is only the start, however, because after identification of the outcome you must then try to trace back the results through the responses and combination of responses if you want to tie them back to a particular disruption. I’m not sure that it is critical to tie everything back to a specific disruption though. The point of this whole exercise is to identify a reaction to mitigate the specific business disruption that has occurred and this should be the initial focus. After the mitigation exercise you will need to go back and evaluate the actions that resulted in the disruption on another day.

Tom Brouillette

Contact: tbrouillette@ncspartners.com

@ncspartners

COVID-19 Crashed Into The Economy

Covid-19 crashed into the economy causing supply and demand side disruption that continues to ripple through the supply chain impacting planning and forecasting in addition to transportation, storage and manufacturing disruption. This disruption requires robust data analytics to sense and respond to the dynamic changes that ripple through the economy. The challenge and first priority is developing the capabilities based on a robust data analytics business intelligence model to sense and respond early to risk so that the impact of the continuously changing disruption. This challenge requires a great deal of imagination and focus in order to develop the tools and framework that is both robust and flexible to respond to the disruption.

This is not a single event, it is a significant event in a series of events that will continue to impact the economy and as a result the extended supply chain into the future. This fundamentally changes your business continuity planning requirements to include a larger number of scenarios and combinations of scenarios in order to manage the risk. In addition to the expansion of risk scenarios this also requires more frequent reviews and most importantly - data analytics to sense the disruption early in the life cycle. This combination of additional and improved strategic business risk scenario evaluation and improved analytics to sense the disruption are key to successful response to limit the impact of the disruption.

We have reached the point now in the global market where these capabilities are critical not to the success of your organization but they are now a critical factor in the survival of your organization! The current situation is a perfect example of how risk is driven by multiple events to disrupt. In the last year we have experienced severe climate related events such as wildfires, hurricanes and tornadoes that impact the market and product demands Then add to this the US / China trade war that initiated the manufacturing shift from China to other Asia Pacific countries. Then before the trade war settled the pandemic crashed into the market first impacting manufacturing and flowing through a shut down of the world economy.

All of these factors come together for a 500 year disruption that must be resolved. We must reset our scope and risk management though to plan for the 500 year disruption continuously. In a global market there are so many factors that influence change and disruption along with the impact of the disruption. These factors change with the season and the relationship and impact of the combination of factors require a focused risk scenario strategy in order to sense the factor early so that the response can be identified to limit the disruption.

It is no longer acceptable to react to the disruption after the fact. The disruptions are coming too quickly and more importantly the disruption builds on previous factors and disruption to create new impacts. Your organization will not be able to survive unless you implement a risk management sense and response strategy that is frequently reviewed and revised for new scenarios and responses. The good news is that the tools are available now to support this initiative and only require the focus and priority to develop and monitor the strategy.